The dilemma: "If they speak out too loudly, resentment builds toward them; if they play by the rules and remain silent, resentment builds inside them." Tempered radicals are informal leaders who want significant change, pursue it in moderate ways, and care about both their organization and their careers. Organizations change through drastic action or evolutionary adaptation. Tempered radicals do the second: "like drops of water… over time and in accumulation, they can erode granite."
| Approach | What it is | Example in the reading |
|---|---|---|
| Disruptive self-expression | Quietly live your values in a visible way. People notice and talk. | John Ziwak leaves at 6 p.m. and refuses evening calls. His performance improves, and colleagues follow. |
| Verbal jujitsu | Turn an insensitive statement or action back into a positive change | Brad Williams: "I'm glad George picked up on Sue's concerns. Sue, did George correctly capture what you were thinking?" |
| Variable-term opportunism | Take short-term openings and also plan longer-term change | Jane Adams shares power in a dog-eat-dog culture. Her division becomes a known training ground. |
| Strategic alliance building | Work with allies, including apparent opponents, to gain legitimacy and speed | Paul Wielgus wins over the auditor scrutinizing his creativity-training department. The program spreads across the company. |
Early 2023. Zach Nimboorkar (SVP Global Technology Services, Enterprise IT) tells Jaroslaw Richert (Barcelona, Hardware IT Asset Governance) and Austin Brunero (Boston, Green IT ambassador) that Green IT has won the SustainableIT.org Impact Award and a Globee Award. His message: the awards are validation, but "the bigger challenge… lay ahead." Goal: cut IT emissions 50%.
| Outcome | Figure | Read it as |
|---|---|---|
| PCs added in 2020 | 11,000, with usage emissions fully offset | Growth decoupled from emissions |
| Server energy consumption | −26% | Cloud migration, legacy decommissioning, weekend shutdowns |
| Scope 1 & 2 (company), 2022→23 | −12% | Green IT contributes, but this is a company-wide figure |
| On-prem server emissions | −26.5% (2021), −30% (2022), then a plateau | The easy wins are used up. Limits to growth. |
| Business case | Cost reduction, talent, reputation, proactive compliance | "Not just a mantra but also a viable business decision" |
| Meyerson approach | Green IT evidence |
|---|---|
| Disruptive self-expression | Richert started in his own area (the PC fleet he governed) and showed results there, without asking for a mandate. Brunero already led his local office Green Team. |
| Strategic alliances | Vendors (Dell, HP, Lenovo) as data allies, the IT Asset Management Board, an external processing partner, and later Corporate Sustainability. He won over potential sceptics with data, as Wielgus did with the auditor. |
| Variable-term opportunism | Short-term: role-based PC allocation, procurement criteria. Long-term: waited until 2021, when leadership wanted "a framework and a common goal across all IT," then scaled. |
| Verbal jujitsu (adapted) | Reframed sustainability from a cost or moral demand into cost savings and resilience, so "IT is part of the problem" became "IT is part of the solution." |
Device carbon data, one version of the truth
Procurement, disposal, allocation policy
CIO backing, an ambassador, four pillars
Employee ideas, ambassadors, comms
White papers, ISO working group, products
| Question | Recommendation | Why |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Employees: deepen engagement across geographies | Move from awareness to defaults and function-level targets: auto power settings, scheduled shutdowns, right-sized hardware, plus a local champions network with each region owning its dashboard. | Brunero: "the difficult part was… getting them to do it in unison." Defaults coordinate behaviour without asking tens of thousands of employees to each decide. |
| 2. Ecosystem: suppliers and partners | Use scope 3: carbon-weighted procurement scoring, refurbished-first purchasing, take-back with disposal vendors, and pushing cloud providers to disclose per workload. | Operational savings have plateaued. The remaining emissions sit in embodied hardware and vendors. |
| 3. Productize internal tools | Yes, through EcoStruxure IT (the sustainability dashboard is already launched). Sell the methodology plus software, using Schneider as the reference customer. | Business IT devices are 54% of sector emissions, so this is the biggest lever. The energy-management market grows from $40.7B to $75.6B (13.2% CAGR). |
| 4. Leading voice | Open-source the measurement methodology through the ISO 19770 working group and SustainableIT.org. Publish assumptions and gaps. | Net positive advocacy (Session 3): raising the industry standard grows the market for Schneider's products and protects its credibility. |
"Schneider's wall is the best thing that could happen to Green IT. It forces the shift from cutting its own footprint to changing the industry's, where the leverage is 100× bigger."
Challenge the "tempered radical" label. Richert had a supportive culture with sustainability in the bonus plan. What would his playbook look like at a company that didn't? That's the harder and more realistic case for most of the room.
Final session, so connect it all: S&S (define the core) → MLF (engage the system) → Nod (design for outcomes) → Schneider (scale from within). Packalen will likely reward a synthesis.
You've run enterprise IAM for 50K+ users. IT asset data (device, role, location) is exactly what Richert used. Speak to how identity and asset data enable role-based right-sizing.
Product analytics instinct: "we had to separate claim from reality" is how good PMs fight HiPPO decisions. Make the parallel between greenwashing and vanity metrics.
As a founder you have formal authority, so your challenge is the reverse of Meyerson's: making change that doesn't depend on you. Mention how you'd build Richert-style measurement into Native so values outlast your attention.
Surana & Surana. A core value is one you'd keep at a cost (Collins & Porras). Be clear about which kind of stakeholderism you mean (Paine).
Maple Leaf. Purpose lives in a system (feedback loops, archetypes). Engagement means choosing how much each stakeholder can change what you do (BSR).
Nod. Choose the right problem, state the mechanism, co-design, and pay for outcomes. Own the consequences you didn't intend (Net Positive, Nohria & Taneja).
Schneider. Measure first, embed in the rules, earn the mandate, then make your practice the industry norm. Change from within, quietly (Meyerson).
Each case turns on whether purpose survives contact with a cost: ₹37.8M at S&S, being too far ahead at MLF, low engagement at Nod, the wall at Schneider.
Dec 20 is where you show it: purpose (S1) → stakeholders (S2) → mechanism (S3) → change from within (S4), applied to Native.