← MBA Hub
MBUS 844 — Session 4

Scaling Purpose: Expanding Impact

Queen's Smith AMBA 2027 · Friday, December 4 · In person, Smith Toronto · AM or PM section · Prof. Kelley A. Packalen
Schneider Electric Green IT (Ivey 2024) Meyerson: Tempered Radicals Change From Within Individual call to action due Dec 20
Block 1 — Radical Change, the Quiet Way (Debra E. Meyerson, HBR 2001)

How to Rock the Boat Without Falling Out

The dilemma: "If they speak out too loudly, resentment builds toward them; if they play by the rules and remain silent, resentment builds inside them." Tempered radicals are informal leaders who want significant change, pursue it in moderate ways, and care about both their organization and their careers. Organizations change through drastic action or evolutionary adaptation. Tempered radicals do the second: "like drops of water… over time and in accumulation, they can erode granite."

ApproachWhat it isExample in the reading
Disruptive self-expressionQuietly live your values in a visible way. People notice and talk.John Ziwak leaves at 6 p.m. and refuses evening calls. His performance improves, and colleagues follow.
Verbal jujitsuTurn an insensitive statement or action back into a positive changeBrad Williams: "I'm glad George picked up on Sue's concerns. Sue, did George correctly capture what you were thinking?"
Variable-term opportunismTake short-term openings and also plan longer-term changeJane Adams shares power in a dog-eat-dog culture. Her division becomes a known training ground.
Strategic alliance buildingWork with allies, including apparent opponents, to gain legitimacy and speedPaul Wielgus wins over the auditor scrutinizing his creativity-training department. The program spreads across the company.
Firm commitments, flexible means. "Rather than pressing their agendas, they start conversations… instead of battling powerful foes, they seek powerful friends."
Meyerson's description of tempered radicals
The emblematic story: Peter Grant, a Black senior executive at a West Coast bank, held about 18 positions over 30 years. Each time he hired, he chose a qualified woman or minority candidate and asked each new hire to do the same. He mentored people who wanted to quit: "If you leave, nothing here will change." By his retirement, more than 3,500 women and minority employees had joined. Small actions repeated and passed on add up to large change.
Block 2 — Schneider Electric's Green IT Program (Ivey W37160, 2024): The Facts

The Setup

Early 2023. Zach Nimboorkar (SVP Global Technology Services, Enterprise IT) tells Jaroslaw Richert (Barcelona, Hardware IT Asset Governance) and Austin Brunero (Boston, Green IT ambassador) that Green IT has won the SustainableIT.org Impact Award and a Globee Award. His message: the awards are validation, but "the bigger challenge… lay ahead." Goal: cut IT emissions 50%.

€34.2B
2022 revenue, €3.5B net income, 160 countries. Founded 1836. UN Global Compact signatory since 2003.
~3%
ICT's share of global emissions (ITU 2015, ~740 Mt CO₂). ITU recommends −42% by 2030 for 1.5°C.
54%
Share of the IT sector's CO₂ from business IT devices. The external opportunity.

Timeline

2015
The ITU report convinces Richert that IT must cut emissions about 5% a year. There's no playbook, so Schneider has a first-mover disadvantage. He decides: "if we want to invest in building something substantial in the sustainability space, we will have to do it with data."
2019–2020
Dell, HP and Lenovo (95% of volume) share device carbon data, and the other 5% is extrapolated. The first standardized report goes out in April 2020. Environmental criteria are added to procurement and disposal policy, which makes Schneider one of the few companies doing so. PCs are allocated by role, and circularity starts: leasing, donations, employee purchase.
2021
Top management formalizes Green IT globally under CIO Elizabeth Hackenson's sponsorship. Brunero becomes the single liaison between Enterprise IT, Corporate Sustainability and Governance. Four pillars: end-user devices and circularity, IT infrastructure (EcoStruxure), business collaboration, green adoption practices. Scope widens to on-premise data centres, cloud and colocation, and distributed sites ("Sustainable-First Hybrid IT").
2022–2023
44,000 content impressions, an internal website, and employee ideas such as Ecosia as the default search engine at no budget cost. Corporate Sustainability asks the Green IT team to help with ISO certification. Green IT appears in the Universal Registration Document. Awards follow.
The wall
On-premise server emissions fall 26.5% (2021) and 30% (2022), then progress "hit a wall," which forces a search for new levers.
Block 3 — What the Numbers Say (Exhibits 2 & 4 + Outcomes)

Measurement Came First

166K
PCs and laptops measured. 21.6M kg CO₂ product carbon footprint. 5,649 MWh/yr.
17% → 31%
Desktops are 17.3% of the fleet but 31.4% of PCF and 35.9% of energy
~50%
Cut in weighted annual footprint from refurbishing (7–8 more years of life). 6,000 PCs reused by 2022.
OutcomeFigureRead it as
PCs added in 202011,000, with usage emissions fully offsetGrowth decoupled from emissions
Server energy consumption−26%Cloud migration, legacy decommissioning, weekend shutdowns
Scope 1 & 2 (company), 2022→23−12%Green IT contributes, but this is a company-wide figure
On-prem server emissions−26.5% (2021), −30% (2022), then a plateauThe easy wins are used up. Limits to growth.
Business caseCost reduction, talent, reputation, proactive compliance"Not just a mantra but also a viable business decision"
Why data mattered so much: Richert saw that narratives without data "could even be considered a case of greenwashing." A "single version of the truth" turned arguments about gaps into conversations about contributions, made targets assignable by function, and made results auditable, which is why Corporate Sustainability later came to IT for help with ISO.
Questions to push on: (1) "Neutralized" emissions and "carbon-negative" searches via Ecosia are claims about offsets and trees, which is Session 2's shifting-the-burden question again. (2) Moving to the cloud moves emissions into vendors' scope 3 rather than eliminating them, unless cloud data centres are cleaner, which Schneider tried to verify through beta programs. (3) Schneider sells energy-management software, so its proof points double as marketing. That calls for extra transparency about assumptions.
Block 4 — Read Schneider Through Meyerson: How a Grassroots Effort Scaled

Richert and Brunero as Tempered Radicals, With Top Cover

Meyerson approachGreen IT evidence
Disruptive self-expressionRichert started in his own area (the PC fleet he governed) and showed results there, without asking for a mandate. Brunero already led his local office Green Team.
Strategic alliancesVendors (Dell, HP, Lenovo) as data allies, the IT Asset Management Board, an external processing partner, and later Corporate Sustainability. He won over potential sceptics with data, as Wielgus did with the auditor.
Variable-term opportunismShort-term: role-based PC allocation, procurement criteria. Long-term: waited until 2021, when leadership wanted "a framework and a common goal across all IT," then scaled.
Verbal jujitsu (adapted)Reframed sustainability from a cost or moral demand into cost savings and resilience, so "IT is part of the problem" became "IT is part of the solution."

The Scaling Path

1 · Measure
Make it visible

Device carbon data, one version of the truth

→
2 · Embed
Change the rules

Procurement, disposal, allocation policy

→
3 · Formalize
Structure + a sponsor

CIO backing, an ambassador, four pillars

→
4 · Mobilize
Bottom-up ownership

Employee ideas, ambassadors, comms

→
5 · Externalize
Industry impact

White papers, ISO working group, products

A tension to raise: Meyerson's tempered radicals work against the culture. Richert worked with a culture that already tied employee bonuses to sustainability metrics. Was he really a tempered radical, or an intrapreneur in a supportive system? The honest answer is that the culture gave him permission, and the data gave him legitimacy with IT colleagues who didn't see sustainability as their job.
Block 5 — Nimboorkar's Four Questions & a Recommendation

How to Get Past the Wall

QuestionRecommendationWhy
1. Employees: deepen engagement across geographiesMove from awareness to defaults and function-level targets: auto power settings, scheduled shutdowns, right-sized hardware, plus a local champions network with each region owning its dashboard.Brunero: "the difficult part was… getting them to do it in unison." Defaults coordinate behaviour without asking tens of thousands of employees to each decide.
2. Ecosystem: suppliers and partnersUse scope 3: carbon-weighted procurement scoring, refurbished-first purchasing, take-back with disposal vendors, and pushing cloud providers to disclose per workload.Operational savings have plateaued. The remaining emissions sit in embodied hardware and vendors.
3. Productize internal toolsYes, through EcoStruxure IT (the sustainability dashboard is already launched). Sell the methodology plus software, using Schneider as the reference customer.Business IT devices are 54% of sector emissions, so this is the biggest lever. The energy-management market grows from $40.7B to $75.6B (13.2% CAGR).
4. Leading voiceOpen-source the measurement methodology through the ISO 19770 working group and SustainableIT.org. Publish assumptions and gaps.Net positive advocacy (Session 3): raising the industry standard grows the market for Schneider's products and protects its credibility.
The strategic insight: the internal program has hit diminishing returns (limits to growth), but its external leverage is 100× larger. Schneider's scale lever isn't its own 166K PCs. It's every enterprise fleet that uses its methodology. Scaling purpose here means moving from doing it to making it the norm.
Watch the conflict of interest: once Green IT is a product, its claims are marketing claims. Keep the internal program's reporting independent (audited, ISO-aligned) and separate from the commercial pitch, or the credibility that made it work becomes a greenwashing risk.
Block 6 — Likely Discussion Questions, With Sharp Answers

Cold-Call Ready

Q1: Why did Green IT succeed when most grassroots sustainability efforts stall?
Three reasons. (1) Measurement before messaging. Data gave it legitimacy and auditability and turned debate into contribution. (2) Embedding in the rules (procurement, disposal, allocation) made change stick without relying on goodwill. (3) A sponsor at the right moment. The CIO formalized it once it had proven itself, and comms waited until gains were benchmarked. Meyerson's evolutionary change, followed by top-down acceleration.
"They earned the mandate before asking for it." Bottom-up proof, top-down scale.
Q2: Should Schneider commercialize its internal Green IT tools?
Yes. The external impact dwarfs the internal. It's shared value: the same capability cuts customers' emissions and grows a market that's expanding at 13% a year. The condition is credibility: publish the methodology and assumptions, keep the internal numbers audited, and don't let the sales pitch shape the measurement.
Q3: Communications: what should change as Green IT goes to more geographies?
Early comms aimed for "synchronous involvement" and fell flat, partly because of remote work. What worked was being present, visual and easy to access, plus asking employees for ideas they could own. At scale: localize (regional champions, local metrics), show ownership (credit ideas publicly), and use defaults so participation doesn't depend on attention. Comms should report results, not slogans.
Q4: What does this case teach about being a change agent from within?
Start inside your own sphere of control (Richert's PC fleet), turn the change into evidence your audience already values (cost, risk, compliance), build alliances with people who hold resources (vendors, governance boards), and be ready when leadership opens a window. That's Meyerson's playbook, and it's the structure of your Dec 20 assignment.
Block 7 — Participation Hooks & Taju's Edge (In-Person, Final Session)

How to Contribute Distinctively

Open Strong

"Schneider's wall is the best thing that could happen to Green IT. It forces the shift from cutting its own footprint to changing the industry's, where the leverage is 100× bigger."

Push Consensus

Challenge the "tempered radical" label. Richert had a supportive culture with sustainability in the bonus plan. What would his playbook look like at a company that didn't? That's the harder and more realistic case for most of the room.

Synthesize the Course

Final session, so connect it all: S&S (define the core) → MLF (engage the system) → Nod (design for outcomes) → Schneider (scale from within). Packalen will likely reward a synthesis.

Taju's Edge: Identity & IT

You've run enterprise IAM for 50K+ users. IT asset data (device, role, location) is exactly what Richert used. Speak to how identity and asset data enable role-based right-sizing.

Taju's Edge: Data Before Story

Product analytics instinct: "we had to separate claim from reality" is how good PMs fight HiPPO decisions. Make the parallel between greenwashing and vanity metrics.

Taju's Edge: Founder as Change Agent

As a founder you have formal authority, so your challenge is the reverse of Meyerson's: making change that doesn't depend on you. Mention how you'd build Richert-style measurement into Native so values outlast your attention.

Block 8 — Bridge to "Making Change from Within" (55%, Due Dec 20)

Use Session 4 as Your Assignment Template

ContextName your sphere of influence honestly (Richert started with what he governed). As Native's founder, also explain why you're approaching this stakeholder first. The rubric asks whether someone "closer to your level" should come first.
FrameworksPick 1–2 used in a sustained way and not reused from the team report. Strong pairs: theory of change + unintended consequences (S3), or Meyerson + BSR mapping (S4 + S2).
StakeholdersA table with influence, interest and stance. Add BSR's vulnerability and trust to stand out. Kids and native-speaker contributors are high-vulnerability, low-influence stakeholders.
ScriptLead with the ask. Speak the stakeholder's language (Schneider sold green IT to IT as cost and resilience). Give data, a phased timeline and a specific next step. No framework names.
FormatMax 1,500 words across three parts (400–500 / 550–650 / 400–500) plus up to 2 pages of appendix. APA. Cadmus. 30/60 individual marks needed to pass the course.
Candidate change opportunities at Native: (1) an outcome-based success metric (spoken use at home) replacing streaks and engagement, from Nod. (2) A responsible AI and child-data policy with canaries, from Nohria & Taneja. (3) A fair-pay and attribution framework for native-speaker content creators and elders, from beneficial stakeholderism. Pick the one where the stakeholder (an investor, a co-founder, a school partner) has a real decision to make.
Block 9 — Course Synthesis: Define → Communicate → Realize → Scale

The Arc of MBUS 844

S1 · Define

Surana & Surana. A core value is one you'd keep at a cost (Collins & Porras). Be clear about which kind of stakeholderism you mean (Paine).

S2 · Communicate

Maple Leaf. Purpose lives in a system (feedback loops, archetypes). Engagement means choosing how much each stakeholder can change what you do (BSR).

S3 · Realize

Nod. Choose the right problem, state the mechanism, co-design, and pay for outcomes. Own the consequences you didn't intend (Net Positive, Nohria & Taneja).

S4 · Scale

Schneider. Measure first, embed in the rules, earn the mandate, then make your practice the industry norm. Change from within, quietly (Meyerson).

The common thread

Each case turns on whether purpose survives contact with a cost: ₹37.8M at S&S, being too far ahead at MLF, low engagement at Nod, the wall at Schneider.

Your exam

Dec 20 is where you show it: purpose (S1) → stakeholders (S2) → mechanism (S3) → change from within (S4), applied to Native.

One sentence to remember: purpose scales when someone makes it measurable, writes it into the rules, and makes it easier for others to adopt than to ignore.
MBUS 844 · Session 4 Prep · Queen's Smith AMBA 2027 · Prof. Kelley A. Packalen · Individual "Making Change from Within" due Sun Dec 20, 23:59 EDT via Cadmus · AI-assisted prep notes (Claude), cite per course GenAI policy