← MBA Hub
MBUS 844 — Session 3

Realizing Purpose: Social Innovation and Business Models

Queen's Smith AMBA 2027 · Thursday, December 3 · In person, Smith Toronto · Morning · Prof. Kelley A. Packalen
Hope & Grit / Nod (Berkeley-Haas 2022) Net Positive Manifesto Unintended Consequences Individual call to action due Dec 20
Reading gap: the syllabus lists They Make It So Easy (NYT, 2020) for this session, but your session-3 folder has The Net Positive Manifesto and Managing the Unintended Consequences of Your Innovations instead. These notes cover the folder. Check the course site for the final list.
Block 1 — The Net Positive Manifesto (Polman & Winston, HBR 2021)

"Is the World Better Off Because Your Company Is in It?"

A net positive company "improves well-being for everyone it impacts and at all scales — every product, every operation, every region and country, and for every stakeholder, including… future generations and the planet itself." No company qualifies yet. The authors' argument is that CSR and philanthropy are "inadequate for our times."

Path 1

Serve stakeholders, then shareholders

J&J's 1943 Credo put stockholders last, with a "fair return." Polman stopped quarterly guidance three weeks into the job. Lifebuoy + UNICEF handwashing: soap donated for neonatal kits branded, not generic, and the brand grew double digits to €1B+.

"You reap profits through purpose."
Path 2

Own all your impacts

Stop "externalizing costs and internalizing profits." Scope 1/2/3 is the start, but lobbying against climate policy cancels out a good footprint. IKEA produces more renewable energy than it uses. Apple co-funded zero-carbon aluminum with Rio Tinto and Alcoa, which Audi now uses: "net positive ripples."

Rabbi Tarfon: "not your responsibility to finish the work… but you are not free to desist from it."
Path 3

Partner, even with critics

Consumer Goods Forum: standard pallets let trucks pack 50%+ tighter. Fashion Pact (2019). Oxfam audited Unilever Vietnam with unrestricted access and published a stand-alone report. Tell productive critics apart from cynics.

Path 4

Net positive advocacy

Work "on the forest, not in the forest." Unilever Russia proposed plastic fees based on material type rather than weight, helping every firm rather than asking for a tax break. Microsoft: carbon-negative by 2030 and all historical emissions removed by 2050. Google: 24/7 carbon-free by 2030.

Evidence cited: Unilever TSR close to 300% during Polman's tenure (Paine in Session 1 has 290% vs a 165% peer median). The article says 80%+ of ESG funds beat their benchmarks in 2020 and 90% of new grid energy in 2020 was renewable. Outside the reading: Unilever's 2017 Kraft Heinz takeover attempt is the usual counter-example on investor patience. Mention it as context, not as a fact from the reading.
Block 2 — Managing the Unintended Consequences of Your Innovations (Nohria & Taneja, HBR 2021)

Founders and Investors Must Own What They Didn't Intend

Merton's (1930s) typology: unforeseen benefits, perverse results, unexpected drawbacks. What's new is speed. Moore's and Metcalfe's laws make harms compound exponentially. A utilitarian "benefits outweigh costs" view has its own unintended consequence: it lets builders off the hook.

Their Typology to Start From (Beyond Generic ESG)

1
Misinformation
2
Concentrated power
3
Privacy breaches
4
Workforce inequality
5
Reduced access
6
Alienation / isolation
7
Environment

The Practices

1

Algorithmic canaries: AI monitors built in from the start (e.g., Allen Institute's Grover, 92% accuracy at telling human from machine-written news) and tracked as OKRs/KPIs, not added after the headlines.

2

From the outset: founders put unintended consequences in pitch decks, and investors probe them in due diligence.

3

Governance: a board subcommittee or an independent body (Facebook's oversight board was being explored at the time).

4

Partner with regulators: FDA-style pre-launch review of harms, ideally faster than the FDA. Self-regulation frameworks first.

Critique to have ready: "use AI to catch the harms of tech" can itself be shifting the burden (Session 2 archetype). Canaries detect symptoms. The root cause is often the business model: engagement-maximizing ads. Nod is a good contrast because it changed the model, not just the monitoring.
Block 3 — Hope and Grit: Human-Centered Design for Student Mental Health (Berkeley-Haas B5995, 2022): The Facts

The Partners

Hopelab (venture philanthropy, Omidyar-founded)

Chris McCarthy (ex-Kaiser Permanente HCD) is VP Strategy & Innovation. Hopelab brings behaviour-change science, an impact strategy, research and evaluation, and funding. Its earlier product, Re-Mission, a game that improved chemo adherence, was validated in RCTs.

Grit Digital Health (developer)

Andrew Baker, VP Product. Grit handles concept development, student co-design, prototyping, branding, engineering, distribution and monetization. Prior work: "YOU at College" (180+ campuses) and "Man Therapy." CEO Joe Conrad sets Grit against The Social Dilemma-style apps.

The Problem in Numbers

67%
of college students felt "very lonely" in the past year. 30% in a two-week window (ACHA 2017).
41%
of leavers in one survey cited feeling socially alone
~$10M
lost per year by the average institution to attrition

Timeline

2017
McCarthy and Baker meet at a SXSW "storystorming" session. Hopelab's systems map of young adults' well-being identifies 7 opportunity areas. Loneliness stands out.
2018
A joint team does root-cause work (the "loneliness gap"), sets intended impact and a theory of change, and runs ethnographic interviews. Five concepts are storyboarded in two days and shown to 100+ students. Risky Business, "a fitness app for your social life," wins.
2019
Pilot at the University of Oregon: 220 incoming students split into app and control groups, and stratified by loneliness on the UCLA scale. With UO Psychology and UCSF.
2020–2021
11 pilot schools and two Fast Company Innovation by Design awards. An Upswing Fund grant takes Nod to Colorado high schools. Post-COVID isolation raises the stakes.
Block 4 — Case Q1–Q3: Systems Thinking → Theory of Change → Design Thinking

Three Tools, Three Different Jobs

Systems thinking
Where to intervene

Map inhibitors and accelerators of well-being and choose an upstream leverage point: loneliness before anxiety, depression and self-harm.

→
Root cause
The "why behind the what"

The loneliness gap between expected and actual friendships, the "best time of your life" myth, falling back on old friends, and missing social skills.

→
Theory of change
How change happens

Long-term: retention ↑, anxiety, depression and suicidality ↓. Short-term pathways: manage expectations, growth mindset, small social risks, attention to others.

→
Design thinking
What to build

Ethnography ("smile at five people") → 4 design principles → 5 storyboards → co-created brand → prototype → pilot.

Design Direction (from Student Insights)

  • Destroy the myth of "magical friendship." "Expectations are that college friendships are supposed to be like magic… Immediate. Big. Effortless."
  • Help students step outside their comfort zone.
  • Help them process setbacks with compassion.
  • Build the friend-making muscle over time.

Features: Ideas (science-based prompts), Reflections (process experiences, reduce self-criticism), Testimonials (normalize awkwardness).

Q1 answer in one line: systems thinking chose the problem (loneliness as the upstream lever), the theory of change chose the mechanism (skills plus small risks, not matchmaking), and design thinking chose the form (a social fitness coach students actually want). Most startups only do the third. Existing social apps that just put strangers together raised stress because they skipped the second. Yik Yak (banned in 2017) is the cautionary example.
Block 5 — Case Q4–Q5: Measuring Success When Declining Engagement Means Impact

The Most Interesting Finding in the Case

Pilot result: significant benefits for students who arrived at elevated risk, protecting against worse sleep, lost social support and weaker campus belonging, even with limited engagement (36.69 pages viewed on average). Nod works like "dosage-based medicine": eventually students shouldn't need it. Measured on DAU or MAU, the pilot would have looked like a failure.

An Outcome Scorecard (Q4)

LevelMetricWho cares
Behaviour (leading)Small social risks taken per week, events attended, new contactsProduct team
PsychosocialUCLA loneliness score, campus belonging, social support, sleep qualityResearchers, counselling
Institutional (lagging)First-to-second-year retention, especially in the high-risk segment. Counselling demand.The buyer: the university
EquityEffect size by race, gender, orientation, first-gen statusMission, DEI offices

Business Model Design

Current

B2B2C license

The university buys a license and students download free. The university as messenger builds trust: the team found who recommends an app "a large contributor to establishing trust." The payer's interest (retention) lines up with the user's (connection).

Recommended

Price per incoming cohort, tied to outcomes

License per first-year class, not per active user, so low engagement never hurts revenue. Add a retention-linked component: if the at-risk cohort's retention rises, Nod shares in the ~$10M attrition savings. Report outcomes, not usage.

Q5: How This Differs From a Typical Startup

Typical startup / big tech

Starts from a solution. Optimizes engagement and time-on-app. Ships first, measures later. Monetizes attention. Risk-tests after scale.

Hopelab + Grit

Starts from the problem and its root cause. Optimizes offline behaviour. Co-designs with users during the build, not after. Controlled pilot before rollout. Health outcomes sit alongside revenue as a goal.

Block 6 — Applying Nohria & Taneja to Nod: What Could Go Wrong?

Even "Tech for Good" Needs Canaries

Unintended consequenceMechanismCanary / mitigation
Shifting the burden (systems)Universities license Nod instead of funding counselling, which is already over-stretchedContract terms: Nod complements care. Escalation routes to clinical help.
Missed crisisAn at-risk student uses a wellness app when they need clinical careScreening prompts, crisis resources, monitoring signs of distress
Privacy and surveillanceMental-health data, with the university as both buyer and authorityStrict data separation and only aggregate reporting to schools. That's in their typology.
Reduced accessStudents without smartphones or at non-licensing schools are left outDirect-to-student or public-health channels
Perverse result"Take small social risks" may steer some students toward risky drinking cultures (the case links loneliness and alcohol use)Curate the challenge library. Personalize to comfort level (pilot feedback).
Engagement driftPilot users asked for more push notifications and incentives, which pull toward the attention modelDefine dosage limits. Make "graduation" from the app a success metric.
Tie to Net Positive Path 2: "take ownership of all impacts" applies to tech for good too. The pilot's request for more notifications is the exact moment a well-intentioned product starts sliding toward engagement maximization. Writing a "no engagement-maximization" rule into the product's governance is how you'd prevent it.
Block 7 — Likely Discussion Questions, With Sharp Answers

Cold-Call Ready

Q1: What are the roles of systems thinking and design thinking, and how do they differ?
Systems thinking works at the problem level: it maps the whole system to find leverage points and root causes, and here it chose loneliness as the upstream lever. Design thinking works at the solution level: empathy with specific users, ideation, prototyping, testing. Systems thinking widens the view. Design thinking narrows it to a person. The theory of change connects them by stating the mechanism the design has to deliver.
"Systems thinking tells you which fight to pick. Design thinking tells you how to win it."
Q2: How should Nod measure success if engagement falls as impact rises?
Measure the behaviour targeted by the intervention, which is supportive social interaction, then psychosocial outcomes, then the buyer's outcome (retention). Usage is an input to watch for dosage, not a goal. The business model has to match: charge per cohort, not per active user, so revenue doesn't reward the wrong behaviour.
Children's ed-tech has the same dilemma. Prodigy-style engagement metrics vs actual learning outcomes. You've lived both sides.
Q3: Is Nod "net positive"?
By Polman and Winston's own standard, which says no company qualifies yet, Nod is on the path. It serves stakeholders first, measures outcomes and co-designs. To get there it would need to own its impacts beyond the user (counselling displacement, data, access) and do system-level advocacy, for example pushing for belonging and retention funding in higher-education policy so the solution doesn't depend on each school's budget.
Q4: Can a company "own" consequences it never intended?
Nohria and Taneja say yes, and they make it practical: anticipate in the pitch, monitor with canaries, govern at board level, partner with regulators. Polman and Winston's Rabbi Tarfon line makes the moral case: you can't finish the work, but you can't walk away from it either. The fair limit is foreseeability plus capacity: you own what you could reasonably anticipate and what you're able to influence, and you have a duty to keep widening both.
Block 8 — Participation Hooks & Taju's Edge (In-Person Session)

How to Contribute Distinctively

Open Strong

"Nod's best result came from students who barely used it. If your metric is engagement, that's a failure. If your metric is impact, it's the whole point, and the business model has to follow."

Push Consensus

The room will celebrate Nod. Raise shifting the burden: if a cheap app license lets a university avoid funding counsellors, the system can end up worse off. Ask how you'd write the contract to prevent that.

Bridge Readings

Nohria and Taneja's canaries monitor harms. Nod redesigned the incentive (outcomes, not attention). Changing the business model beats monitoring, which is net positive Path 2 in practice.

Taju's Edge: Native

Native faces Nod's question for kids: does the app succeed when a child speaks Yoruba with their grandmother off the app? Define "graduation" metrics (conversations at home), not streaks. This can anchor your Dec 20 individual assignment.

Taju's Edge: Growth PM

You've run A/B tests on 3M+ users. Argue for what a PM would actually do: an RCT-style holdout like the Oregon pilot as standard practice for any impact claim. Most impact apps never run one.

Taju's Edge: Micro-Drama

Short-form, cliffhanger-driven apps are built to maximize engagement. Being candid about where an attention model like Afro Shorts' needs canaries (binge loops, spending on coins) will land better than lecturing about big tech.

Block 9 — Connections & Assessment Links

Where Session 3 Shows Up Again

Individual (Dec 20): Context

The context statement needs 1–2 frameworks "applied in a sustained way," not the ones from your team report. Theory of change plus unintended consequences is a strong pair for a Native initiative (e.g., an outcome-based success metric, or a responsible-AI and data policy for kids).

Individual: Script

Script rule: no framework names. Nod's lesson translates without jargon: "we'll measure whether kids speak the language at home, not minutes in the app."

↔ Session 2

Hopelab's process began with a systems map, which is the module note in action. The shifting-the-burden archetype applies directly to the counselling risk.

↔ Session 1

Paine's beneficial stakeholderism needs "defined goals for each stakeholder group." Nod's outcome scorecard is exactly that.

→ Session 4 (Scale)

Nod's open question is scaling: 11 pilots to many campuses and into high schools. Session 4 asks how impact scales.

↔ Marketing I

Design thinking (Empathize → Define → Ideate → Prototype → Test) here serves social outcomes rather than product–market fit. Same tool, different objective.

One sentence to remember: social innovation works when you choose the right problem (systems), state how change happens (theory of change), build with the people affected (design), and pay for outcomes rather than attention (business model).
MBUS 844 · Session 3 Prep · Queen's Smith AMBA 2027 · Prof. Kelley A. Packalen · Individual "Making Change from Within" due Sun Dec 20, 23:59 EDT · AI-assisted prep notes (Claude), cite per course GenAI policy