← MBA Hub
MBUS 825 — Session 4

Business Models for Growth & Transformation

Queen's Smith AMBA 2027 · November 15 · Virtual · 2:30–6:30 · Andrea Hunt, MBA
Maison Singulier Case Business Model Canvas Brand Platforms Ad Experimentation Dial-an-Executive
Block 1 — Reinventing Your Business Model (Johnson, Christensen & Kagermann, HBR 2008)

Great Technology Loses to a Great Business Model

Diamond's Rio (1998) and Best Data's Cabo (2000) beat the iPod to market. Apple won by wrapping good technology in a business model: iPod + iTunes, a reverse razor-and-blades where low-margin songs locked in high-margin hardware. It became ~$10B in three years and ~50% of Apple's revenue.

Four Interlocking Elements

1 · Most important

Customer Value Proposition

Help customers get an important job done. The CVP is stronger the more important the job, the lower satisfaction with current options, and the better and cheaper your solution. Precision matters most: nail one job. Common barriers are wealth, access, skill and time (QuickBooks breaks skill; MinuteClinic breaks time).

2

Profit Formula

Revenue model (price × volume), cost structure, margin model, and resource velocity (asset turns). Start from the price that delivers the CVP and work backwards to costs, margins and the scale needed.

3

Key Resources

People, technology, products, facilities, channels and brand. Focus on those that create differentiated value and on how they interact.

4

Key Processes

Repeatable operational and managerial processes, plus rules, norms and metrics. These are often the last to emerge and the first line of defence against change (e.g. "gross margins must be 40%").

Exemplars

CaseJob / CVPWhat had to change
Tata NanoA safer alternative for scooter families (wealth barrier). ~1 lakh (~$2,500).Lower margins and volume. A young team free of old formulas. 85% outsourced, ~60% fewer vendors. Modular assembly by entrepreneurs.
HiltiContractors make money using tools, not owning them, so sell tool fleet managementAssets move onto Hilti's balance sheet. Monthly fees. Reps sell to CFOs. IT, warehousing, repair.
Dow Corning → XiameterExperienced buyers want no-frills silicone cheap (−15%)Separate unit and brand. Web-only, strict rules (fixed order sizes, 2–4 week lead time, paid service). Paid back in 3 months; online share went to 30%. It helped protect core premium pricing.

When You Need a New Model (Five Circumstances)

  1. Disrupt by serving people shut out because existing solutions are too expensive or complex (Nano).
  2. Wrap a new technology in a model (iPod), or take a tested technology to a new market.
  3. Bring a jobs-to-be-done focus where none exists (FedEx).
  4. Fend off low-end disruptors.
  5. Respond to a shifting basis of competition (Hilti vs "good enough" low-end tools).
Rules of thumb to quote: new models usually go through about four revisions before profitability. Be "patient for growth, impatient for profit." Fewer than 10% of innovation investment goes to business models, and 11 of 27 companies that grew into the Fortune 500 in a decade did it through business model innovation. A new model is only worth it if it is new or game-changing to the industry.
Block 2 — Building Your Own Brand Platform (Wichmann, Wiegand & Reinartz, HBR 2022)

Sidestep Amazon by Building a Brand Flagship Platform

Aggregators (Amazon, Google Shopping) start the journey with category searches, standardize product pages, push comparison on price and ratings, and turn brands into suppliers. The answer is a brand flagship platform: a direct interface that brings consumers and third parties into value creation across the whole need category. Nike's apps and site did $9.1B in 2021 (up from $5.5B), about 21% of revenue.

Instrument · low sourcing / low sending

Philips Sonicare. Transactions and feature extensions. Cold loyalty (functional). High control. Users leave for a better deal.

Guide · high sourcing / low sending

Mars Whistle (vets on demand). Third-party expertise in complex, safety-critical categories. Warm loyalty. Risk: brand dilution and generic feel.

Canvas · low sourcing / high sending

Lego Ideas. Users create and share; popular builds become products and creators earn royalties. Warm loyalty through identification. Risk: hijacking and moderation.

Companion · high / high

Bosch DIY & Garden. Guides, community, experts and services grow with the user. Hot loyalty. Risks: dilution, hijacking (users praising rivals), high cost.

Crowdsourcing = participants draw value from others. Crowdsending = participants contribute value. Loyalty: cold = repeat buying, warm = attachment, hot = strong identification.

  • Ease in. Douglas started with 20 partners in adjacent categories, then added 70 more, tripling assortment while protecting positioning.
  • Be willing to share. Goldman's Simon only took off after opening research tools and spinning off equity to rival banks.
  • It isn't cheap. Adidas paid $240M for Runtastic, a 280-person unit.
  • Change the metrics. A balanced scorecard across value to the brand (products + intermediation fees), to third parties and to consumers. Netflix tracks viewing time, not just subscribers.
Block 3 — It's Time to Close the Experimentation Gap in Advertising (Campbell et al., Business Horizons 2022)

Marketers Know Experiments Work, and Still Don't Run Them

1.4–29.4%
Share of Facebook advertisers running any experiment, by industry (Runge et al. 2020)
85% / 25%
Marketers who experiment at all vs. those who test the majority of activity (n=100 senior execs, ~$20B budgets)
9%
Strongly agree they could forecast ROI from a 10% spend change

Experimentation drives ≥20% improvements on ad impact and spend efficiency (one CPG found 35% cost improvement). Bing gained 12% revenue (>$100M a year) from one headline-display test. eBay's randomized tests showed its paid search ROI was negative, because ads hit users who would have bought anyway. That's invisible without holdouts.

Four Myths

MythRealityHow champions handle it
Too complex without a dedicated teamAnyone can run an A/B test: change one variable, randomizeCulture substitutes for a team. "A three-person analytics team… that's all we need."
Needs specialized softwareRandomized tests only need the ad's own outcome data, and data doesn't need to be co-locatedUse free tools (Ads Manager, Conversion Lift)
Needs big dataSmall tests detect big effectsTest bolder differences and pool data over time
Holdouts are wasteful"Without testing, how will you know if an entire campaign is wasteful?"Stop early, use bandits, run 10–15% holdouts. A control group is a delayed sale, not a lost one.

The Decision Ladder (Figure 1)

Gold standard
Randomized control trial

Randomize, with a no-ad control: true incrementality

Next
A/B test

Randomize between ads, no control: which ad wins

Next
Split test

Not fully random but still directional

Next
Geo-experiment

Assign by region (DMA, postal code)

Fallback
Marketing mix model

Use spend variation over time

Culture beats tools: curiosity, evidence that overrules opinion, not penalizing failed concepts, and a small set of agreed KPIs. Firms that improved measurement also reported more spend on digital (83%), more spend on experiments (64%), a higher marketing share of revenue (59%) and better CEO access (50%).
Block 4 — Types of Customer Segmentation (Syllabus Question)

Choose the Basis That Predicts Behaviour You Can Act On

BasisExamplesGood forLimit
DemographicAge, income, life stage, householdMedia buying and sizingWeak predictor alone (Guillén, Session 6: "generations exist only in our imagination")
GeographicCity core vs suburb, country, climateChannel, logistics, local relevanceHides within-place variety
PsychographicValues, lifestyle, personality, self-conceptMessage and creative toneHarder to target directly
BehaviouralUsage, loyalty, RFM, channel, occasionCRM, retention, performance targetingDescribes what, not why
Needs / benefit / JTBDThe job, the desired outcome, risk toleranceProduct and CVP designRequires qualitative depth
Value / customer-typeCLV tiers; Loyals, Switchers, Winbacks, Prospects (Stengel)Budget allocationNeeds data maturity

The Maison Singulier research report is a psychographic and behavioural segmentation layered on demographics. That's exactly what's needed for marketing communications, because message, source and channel all depend on values and media habits.

Block 5 — Maison Singulier: Marketing Communications for an Online Vintage Furniture Store (Ivey W25404)

The Situation

Elif Filyos, a former Instagram interior-design influencer, launched Maison Singulier in Montreal in October 2020. She curates stylish vintage pieces from local marketplaces, repairs and cleans them, and sells them online. The differentiator is harmonious curation: finding "diamond in the rough" pieces that work together.

20,000
Instagram followers in the first six months
75%+
Of all pieces offered sold within six months, to customers across Canada and the US
2 pillars
Sponsored FB/IG posts featuring one product, plus collaborations with aligned influencers

Category tailwinds: antiques and collectibles grew 5.3% (2015–20), forecast +3.5% to 2025. Vintage means 20+ years old and an exemplar of its period's style. Its benefits are exclusivity and self-expression, affordability vs new designer pieces, and sustainability (a second life, circular economy).

The decision (June 2021): research has profiled two target segments. Filyos must build a formal profile of each, then decide the key message, the communication source, the content type and the channels.

The Two Segments, Side by Side

Vintage HuntersSettlers
Who20s, urban core, early career, first real disposable incomeLate 30s, just outside the city, partner and often young kids
LifestyleYoga and gym, streaming, weekend bars and hikes with friendsFamily-centred, restaurants and walks, music and books, healthy eating
MediaInstagram, lifestyle and design influencers, local vintage accountsFacebook (community and parent groups), Twitter, news
ValuesSelf-expression, equality, freedom of expression. Brands as part of self-concept. Status via uniqueness.Environment, family, health, morality. Society over self. Long-term focus.
Decision styleEmotional, design-led, "follow their hearts." Comfortable with ambiguity.Effortful comparison on price, durability and environmental impact. Low tolerance for uncertainty.
Vintage attitudeFluent and comfortable. Pride in the "find," and they share finds with friends.Curious but wary: "used" means defects and risk. Open to being convinced, and might become an antiquing hobby.
Purchase frequencyDecorating actively, follows drops even when not buyingRarely buys (staying long-term), buys functional pieces when needed
Funnel stageAwareness high, so the job is conversion and advocacyAwareness low and trust low, so the job is education and risk reduction
Block 6 — The Marketing Communications Plan: Message, Source, Content, Channel

One Brand Promise, Two Executions

"Pieces with a past, curated for your future."
Suggested umbrella: curation is the constant; Hunters hear "past = uniqueness," Settlers hear "past = proven durability and sustainability"
DecisionVintage HuntersSettlers
ObjectiveConvert faster and turn them into advocates and recruitersBuild understanding and trust, then a first purchase
Key message"The piece no one else has." Find it first and make your space yours."Built to last. Restored, inspected, guaranteed." Better for your home, your budget and the planet.
AppealEmotional: scarcity, pride, identityRational plus moral: durability, value, environmental impact, family legacy
SourceFilyos as tastemaker, design micro-influencers, peers sharing finds (social proof)Expert sources: the restorer, Filyos as specialist, real local families. Credibility over celebrity.
ContentReels of the "find," weekly drop teasers, styled rooms, before/after restoration, "tag the friend who needs this"Long-form guides ("How we restore a 1970s teak dresser"), condition reports, cost-per-year and carbon comparisons vs new, family home tours
ChannelInstagram (feed, Stories, Reels), drop alerts by SMS or emailFacebook community and parent groups, Facebook ads, email nurture, website blog and search
Risk reducersHolds and reservations, fast checkout (avoid losing the find)Detailed photos and defect disclosure, warranty and returns, delivery and assembly, "first-piece" guarantee

Communications Process Checklist (Use This Structure in the Write-Up)

1

Target audience profile (Block 5 table).

2

Objectives by funnel stage: Hunters (conversion, advocacy) vs Settlers (awareness of benefits, trust).

3

Message: what to say (content), how to say it (structure and appeal), and who says it (source credibility = expertise + trustworthiness + likeability).

4

Channels and content formats per platform culture (Session 6: each platform has its own language).

5

Budget split: Hunters respond quickly (performance). Settlers need a longer nurture (brand and content). Don't judge Settlers on 7-day ROAS.

6

Measurement and experiments: A/B test the Settler message ("sustainable" vs "durable" vs "value"), run holdouts on influencer posts, and use a geo-test of Facebook-group ads in two suburbs.

The tension to name: Hunter content (scarcity, "gone in an hour") raises Settlers' anxiety. Settlers need certainty, time and guarantees. Keep the channels separate (IG vs FB) and give Settlers a calmer "Essentials" collection of durable, functional pieces with longer availability.
Block 7 — Applying the Business-Model Lens to Maison Singulier

Communications Won't Fix a Supply-Constrained Profit Formula

CVP

Curated uniqueness, made safe

For Hunters the job is "express myself and get the find." For Settlers it's "furnish responsibly without risk." Same curation, different job.

Profit formula

Resource velocity is the bottleneck

Every SKU is one-of-a-kind and has to be sourced, repaired and photographed. Selling 75% of pieces in six months means supply is likely capping growth. Bulky cross-border shipping squeezes margins.

Key resources

Filyos's eye and audience

Founder taste is the asset and the scaling limit (Supreme parallel). Codify the curation (a style guide, trained sourcers).

Platform play

From store to "canvas"

Consignment ("crowdsending" supply from Settlers' attics), UGC styled homes, restorer partners ("guide"). This could become a vintage companion platform for the Montreal community.

Smart extension: a consignment and trade-in program solves supply and converts Settlers. They sell an old piece first (low risk), then trust the brand enough to buy.
Block 8 — Likely Discussion Questions, Participation & Dial-an-Executive

Cold-Call Ready

Q1: Should Maison Singulier target both segments, or focus?
Both, but sequenced and separated. Hunters are the core engine (already converting, high advocacy, Instagram-native). Settlers are the growth segment (bigger baskets, more income, and sustainability values that fit vintage) but need education and risk reduction. Keep one brand promise (curation), use different channels and messages, and allocate budget by funnel stage. The risk of a single blended message is that it bores Hunters and scares Settlers.
The Native parallel: the kids are the "hunters" (engagement), the parents are the "settlers" (risk-averse buyers who need proof). Two audiences, one product, deliberately different comms.
Q2: Who is the right communication source for Settlers?
An expert and a peer like them: the restorer explaining construction quality, and local families showing pieces holding up with kids. Lifestyle influencers have referent power, which suits Hunters. Settlers respond to expert power (French & Raven, Session 6 reading) and to evidence. Filyos herself can shift from tastemaker to specialist.
Use the JOLT logic (Session 6): Settlers' problem is indecision, not status quo. Offer a recommendation, limit options and take risk off the table (guarantee).
Q3: Is this a business model question or a comms question?
The case asks a comms question, but the strongest answer flags the business model constraint. With 75% sell-through, demand isn't the binding constraint, sourcing is. Comms that drive more demand without more supply create disappointed customers. Pair the comms plan with a supply play (consignment, sourcing partners). That's Johnson–Christensen's resource-velocity point.
An operator's instinct: find the binding constraint before spending on growth.
Open Strong

"Hunters buy uniqueness; Settlers buy certainty. Same product, opposite emotional job, so opposite comms."

Experiment Angle

Propose a concrete test: an A/B of the Settler headline plus a 10–15% holdout on influencer spend. Use the article's numbers.

Taju's Edge: Founder-Influencer

Filyos's audience is the moat and the key-person risk. Building beyond the founder's feed is the scaling step every creator-led brand hits.

Questions for the Dial-an-Executive Guest

  • When did your business model, not your marketing, become the growth constraint, and how did you spot it?
  • How much of your media budget sits in always-on experiments, and who owns the results?
  • Have you built (or killed) a brand platform or community? What metric told you it worked?
Individual Assignment (due Nov 29)

This is the last session before the deadline. For Q2, segmentation and business-model language sharpens the Lululemon vs Lee Valley contrast (community platform vs expert-guide catalogue). For Q3 (telecom), use segmentation types to name the core target precisely.

→ Session 5

The experimentation culture feeds directly into the metrics roadmap and budgeting when money is tight.

→ Session 6

Influencer selection (fit vs reach) and platform culture apply directly to Maison Singulier's two pillars.

One sentence to remember: Segment by the job and the fear. Hunters fear missing out, Settlers fear messing up, so the same curated product needs two different conversations.
MBUS 825 · Session 4 Prep · Queen's Smith AMBA 2027 · Andrea Hunt · Individual Assignment (30%) due Nov 29 · AI-assisted prep notes (Claude), cite per course GenAI policy